Alright, so first of all…try to ignore the subscript under the title of this blog that says “Light food that doesn’t skimp on flavor”….because this recipe definitely isn’t light. But, come on…its Christmas! No matter how healthy you like to eat, there are certain occasions in which you have to let that go and indulge in junk food. Christmas is DEFINITELY one of those occasions.
If you are so strict with your eating that you won’t even cheat around Christmas, then…well…just do it anyway just this once so you can try these Peppermint Bark Oreo Pops. They are so Christmasy and delicious! If you have read my “About Me” page, then you know I am absolutely in love with Christmas. It is my favorite time of year BY FAR. So making holiday treats like this is so much fun for me.
I’m really not much of a baker, I barely know anything about it. So when I make desserts like this, they are rarely difficult or complex. This recipe is so easy. Anyone can make it. This December has been a little strange because my husband, Seth, has been out in the field since December 2nd. He is home on weekends, so that is better than nothing, but it has still been pretty quiet around the apartment. However… I refuse to let my Christmas month be sad, so I am overcompensating with constant Christmas music, Christmas movies, Christmas baking (if you can call it baking), and decking out my apartment in decorations. So despite his absence, it has still been an awesome Christmas!
So on that note…Peppermint Bark Oreo Pops. These things are so good. I loooove peppermint bark. I make it every year. So this year I wanted to do something a little different with it, and I thought these would be tasty. And they definitely were.
So you start by chopping three 4 oz bars of white chocolate. I just used Bakers chocolate.
You don’t have to “shave” the chocolate, but you do want it to be in relatively small pieces so it melts faster.
Fill a medium pot with a few inches of water, and place a heat proof bowl on top (glass works). This is called a double boiler, and it’s a great way to melt chocolate. If you don’t have the materials to do this, just microwave the chocolate in small increments of time, stirring often, until it is smooth and melted.
Bring your water to a simmer, and stir the chocolate very often as it melts. Try to not let the water boil against the bottom of the bowl, it should just be gently simmering beneath it.
Meanwhile, throw about 15-20 peppermints in a large ziplock bag and, using a rolling pin, take your anger out on the little candies and whack them repeatedly until they are transformed into peppermint dust/tiny peppermint pieces. If you don’t have a rolling pin, you can use a pan to do this.
Poor peppermints. This picture is actually a bad example, the pieces should be smaller than this. It should be more like peppermint dust with various little tiny pieces of peppermint.
So once your chocolate is completely melted and smooth like this–
–stir in 1/2 teaspoon of peppermint extract. Try your chocolate. If you think it needs more peppermint flavor, add a little more extract. I thought 1/2 teaspoon was a perfect amount.
Now it’s time to prep your Oreos!
Stick a skinny Popsicle stick into the middle of each Oreo while you are lightly squeezing both sides together so it doesn’t pop apart. Push the Popsicle stick up a little into the Oreo frosting, but not so much that it pokes through the top. I’m not sure any of that made sense…so I took pictures to show you what I mean.
It’s super easy. This recipe made 16 Oreo pops for me, so I would start with prepping that many and then if you have left over chocolate, go ahead and prep a few more at the end.
Now line a baking sheet with parchment or wax paper. Take an Oreo and dip it into the chocolate, using a spoon to help you cover the entire cookie with chocolate. Towards the end, I basically just put the Oreo into the bowl and spooned chocolate onto it until the Oreo was sufficiently covered because the chocolate wasn’t deep enough to dip the whole cookie.
Continue dipping your cookies until they are all done, and then sprinkle a little bit of your crushed peppermint onto each one.
And that’s it!
If you are eager like me and don’t want to wait for the chocolate to set up on its own, you can pop the baking sheet in the freezer and they will be ready in just a few minutes.
**If you are planning on transferring them to the freezer or fridge, make sure you use the baking sheet and not just plain parchment/wax paper. If you don’t, the Oreo pops will slide all over the place when you lift the paper, and they won’t be nearly as pretty. I learned this the hard way…**
Once the chocolate is set, you are ready to go!
One more…this one has my Christmas tree in the background!
Here is the recipe:Print
Peppermint Bark Oreo Pops
- Prep Time: 20 mins
- Cook Time: 5 mins
- Total Time: 25 mins
- Yield: 16 Oreo Pops 1x
- Three 4oz bars of white chocolate (I used Bakers)
- About 15–20 peppermint candies
- 1/2 teaspoon peppermint extract
- 16–20 skinny Popsicle sticks
- Finely chop the white chocolate
- Fill a medium pot with a few inches of water, and place a heat proof bowl (glass works) inside it to make a double boiler
- The water shouldn’t be touching the bottom of the bowl
- Bring the water to a simmer
- Add the chocolate to the bowl
- Stir the chocolate often until it is completely melted and smooth
- Meanwhile, place the peppermint candies in a ziplock bag and, using a rolling pin (or a pan), crush the candies until you have peppermint dust mixed with very small peppermint pieces
- Once your chocolate is melted, stir in the peppermint extract
- For the Oreos, stick a skinny Popsicle stick into the center of each one, gently squeezing each side as you do so that it doesn’t pop open
- Push the stick into the Oreo a little bit, but not enough so that it pops through the top
- Prep 16 Oreos (if you have extra chocolate at the end, you can prep a few more)
- Place a sheet of parchment or wax paper onto a baking sheet
- Dip the Oreos into the white chocolate until they are completely covered, using a spoon to help cover the whole cookie in chocolate
- Towards the middle of this process, I wasn’t dipping the Oreos because the chocolate wasn’t deep enough. I just held the Oreo down in the bowl and spooned chocolate onto it until it was sufficiently coated
- Place the Oreos onto the parchment/wax paper once they are dipped
- After all the Oreos are finished, sprinkle a little bit of peppermint on top of each one
- You can place these in the freezer or fridge to help the chocolate set faster if you want
Shiran @ Pretty. Simple. Sweet. says
These are beautiful looking pops Annie! Love the idea, and how easy they are to make!
Annie Chesson says
Thank you Shiran! They are pretty yummy :). And very Christmassy!